A TALE OF TWO REUNIONS
An extremely long meditation on friendship and whining
Dear Amy, Barbara and Susan,
As I begin this missive, the three of you are likely settling in with second cups of coffee, planning the deliciously long reunion day stretching before you. I so wish I were with you. The peace I feel after canceling at the last minute tells me I made the right decision, overall. Still...
My hasty email gave you only the sketchiest reasons for bailing so unceremoniously, and now I would like to fill in those blanks. In decades past, a conventional wisdom advised: Never complain, never explain. But the absence of explanation seems to have already cost me one friendship this year, and I'm not about to risk the loss of three more.
Our writers’ reunion was to proceed thus: for me, a leisurely 90-minute drive down the coast of Lake Michigan to Michigan City, Indiana. There I would join you: the three other Midwesterners whom I met 12 years ago in Litchfield, Conn, where we underwent an intensive three-day training to certify as leaders of creative writing workshops. After training, we returned to our home cities to establish our own workshops, using our newly minted Amherst Writers and Artists magic to encourage aspiring writers to conquer their fears and find their clear, determined inner voices.
Thanks to Barbara's organizational skills, we planned to come together today and share all that has happened since. I so anticipated hearing your stories and advice, looking forward to that ride along the coast as I imagined gradually separating myself from the everyday and formulating questions for all of you.
As you know, the cosmos had other plans: I would not after all be traveling alone southward from Holland, but rather north from Cincinnati, a five-hour drive. My husband would drop me off at your place, continue home on his own and return two days later to fetch me back.
We’d been called to Cincinnati to attend a memorial service for Howard's cousin Kent, whose death from cancer had left us reeling -- just three months from diagnosis to departure. We needed to be there, no way would we have missed it. The cousins had been close as boys, and as a foursome we had clicked and enormously enjoyed our visits. We’d been planning a road trip rendezvous when the diagnosis came in. Howard was quite cut up at the loss of his boyhood buddy and he struggled to write the memorial presentation that Sharon, Kent's wife, had requested.
Since the beginning of this year, both of us have struggled to make peace with multiple illnesses and deaths of people we love. These include two dire diagnoses (one fatal, as you have seen). Among our Michigan neighbors, an uncommonly close group, J nearly died following surgery, R nearly died after 20 minutes without a heartbeat following a sudden blackout, and B had a melanoma dug from her leg. In a horrific finale, neighbor S died alone on a country road, presumably of heart failure, where he had been enjoying a bike ride.
The friendships here at the NuMooring are such that when one of us is down, the rest suffer as well. Slowly, and without our realizing, grief and worry had become the underlayment of Howard's and my summer. I slid into a black depression that settled in like a bad toothache, from which I’ve only recently begun to emerge. I am learning, as I grow older (70 next May), that I don't as easily shrug off life's slings and arrows. As the wounds increase, resilience is progressively compromised, so that setbacks of the kind I've described form an accretion-- a shoulder boulder, if you will.
Just two weeks prior to our writers reunion, Howard had to go to the ER for intractable back pain that had been building for several days. The staff ran tests and found nothing, sending him home with heavy drugs that only partially relieved the pain. Finally he was okay, but we both took this as a wake-up call, a flashing neon arrow aimed at the path of healthier habits. (We had a similar sighting back in 2010, after his heart attack and five stents. The resolve to stay on that path of redemption, however, is easily eroded.)
The funeral weekend played out, Howard got through his tribute to Kent, speaking masterfully and inspiring the congregation with a hilarious account of two-long ago boys' mischief with their pea-shooters,
By Sunday night, we were relieved yet drained. Overnight my thoughts turned to the reunion. All of this driving was doing his back no good...and there would be another round facing him on Wednesday to bring me home. I worried about the gale force wind and storm that had blasted across our Holland property over the weekend. What would Howard find when he got there? And on and on.
I am the once-impulsive woman who often airily proclaimed " Worry is a useless indulgence." (Corollary to another favorite, "Guilt is a useless emotion.") But yesterday, in the end, I gave in to the useless indulgence. I sent you good women my reunion regrets, and drove home with my husband. Now, my friends, you know the full story.
Reunion #2
Earlier (MUCH earlier) I spoke of another well-intentioned failure to tell the whole story, and how it ended a friendship. This, too, is the tale of a reunion.
I had a precious friend of decades' standing. We were young together during that indelible season: the discovery of life. We now live in distant cities, so every April we can manage, we have a blossomy, balmy reunion weekend at an inn that is equidistant from our homes, about a two-hour drive. It has always been a soul-filling time of shared memories, current-day philosophizing and gales of laughter.
This year, though, we had to schedule our date in early March. I had some trepidations about the timing. The choir I sing with had been preparing intensively (Schubert's Mass in A flat Major) for a concert at Carnegie Hall. The concert date was just ten days from my reunion with Erica. In between would come a four-day visit from our Texas son and grandson. This, for me, is a lot to pack into a two-week period, but there was no alternative to the reunion date and no way I'd miss a chance to meet up with Erica. I kept my trepidations to myself.
A frigid wind blew through the Midwest that morning of my departure for the inn. I realized not long after I set off that I had forgotten a critical pre-travel step: I had failed to wrap my wrists. I have basal joint arthritis in both hands and cannot drive more than an hour unsupported before they begin to ache and cramp. When I reached the inn, I took an aspirin, the first of several as the afternoon and evening progressed. A hard choice for me, because aspirin makes me drowsy. In the meantime, I was dealing with another issue. Since January I had been fighting a weepy eye, which no doctor had been able to diagnose and treat. Depending on who knows what factor, the eye would overflow, tears coursing down my cheek, the salt irritating sensitive under-eye skin. Cold weather made the condition worse.
These are niggling issues, right? And Erica has her own far more serious ongoing issues, about which she never complains. Erica is a poster girl for the old don’t-complain/explain adage. So I decided to suck it up and say nothing of my own stuff; how trivial it sounded in comparison. We had our typical first-night room party, with wine, cheese and crackers fueling a gabfest in which despair over the current political situation figured prominently. When we retired to our separate rooms, I took more aspirin, wrapped one wrist in a scarf and the other in a long sock, and prayed for sleep. It came.
I was definitely groggy and off my game the next day, but thought Erica didn't notice as we visited our favorite boutique and ate lunch in town. In the afternoon, I begged off our usual swim session in the free-standing indoor pool across the way, saying only that the day was too cold for me, even in my heaviest winter coat. What was actually going on in my brain: It’s cold, all right! Did you not feel that wind? Do you want to get a chill right before Carnegie Hall? Or expose your weird eye thing to the unknowns of a public pool?! Girl. Show some sense! So I sent Erica on to the pool by herself and I went to use the fitness room treadmill instead. As I walked back, endorphins now pumping, I thought of the hot shower awaiting me, and a wonderful rest of the reunion with my friend.
I checked in with Erica, then headed for the shower. When I emerged, I found a note under the door. "I decided to head back home. I don't feel comfortable staying. You seem to want to be on your own. Take care, Erica." I raced to her room and hammered on the door. There was no answer, of course. I couldn't call her because my cell phone wasn't getting a signal. But I was furious and wanted her to know it, so I sent an email: " Erica -- I can't believe you would do this. How can you possibly know what's in my head unless you ask? I am so disappointed. Shocked."
Back in St Louis, I discovered she had unfriended me on Facebook and probably blocked my emails as well. There's been no further contact. I expect none. Do I feel responsible? No. I gave the best I had to give. I know that I am a faithful friend, one who would have had Erica's back forever, as I thought she had mine. This hasn’t been pleasant, not at all. But now it’s over--and that, as they say, is that.
Within the past month, two women friends--my contemporaries-- have publicly apologized for what they termed "whining" or "dumping on friends." (Whining is most unfashionable, you know. Try googling “whining and friendship”) These two friends guiltily mention the disasters of the wider world, balanced against their own paltry concerns. I say this is wrong. It’s apples and oranges. The first woman is currently healing from an injury that has badly compromised her ability to walk. The second has been struggling with a parent descending into dementia, and her own bewildering journey as she tries to wisely and sensitively dispatch her duties as sole caregiver. Neither of these friends is a spineless nitwit complaining about first world problems. In these scenarios, nobody's kvetching about the lawn crew not showing up.
As my mother was dying over several agonizing years, I don't believe I wrote about it publicly until the very last day, in this space. No, I haven't wanted to be a Debbie Downer either. But increasingly I feel that selective whining can be a constructive thing. Maybe as we reach a certain age, we need to tell others what's really going on with us, to speak up if we feel we have some splainin' to do. Otherwise, despite our best intentions, something really important could end up as a crumpled scrap of paper at our feet.
All love to you, Amy, Barbara and Susan. Till our next reunion ----